Does God Exist? Frank Turek vs. Dennis Normark

By: Curtis Ophoven 0 Comments   3/27/2014

One of the best debates I have even seen.  Frank Turek (Christian) takes on Dennis Normark (Non-Theist) who claims he is a non-theist rather than an atheist, yet at one point in the debate Dennis calls himself an atheist.

Frank was in for a challenge as the moderator was also an Atheists. 

From the very beginning he was clearly skeptical, yet he did a pretty good job giving each of them the same time and questions.  

Later in the debate we found out why Dennis makes this distinction that he is a Non-Theist rather than an Atheist.  It seems that Dennis avoids the label of Atheist in order to avoid being grouped with the Atheists leaders that have killed 100 million in the last century, namely Mao, Paul Pot and Stalin. 

Dennis claims that the reason these guys got it wrong was because they took on religious ideas to gain power.  So these devoid Atheists leaders’ who killed millions of people did it because they were corrupted by religion.  In this way, Dennis can suggest that religion is the real enemy of man and if the world would just rid itself of all religion than we would be able to have world peace.

In his opening statement, Frank pointed out that God is the most logical and reasonable cause of all the modern scientific and historical evidence we have.  The real world reveals a real God.

Dennis had no evidence to the contrary, but argued that god is not real but only something in our minds that we imagine in order to answer the questions that we cannot otherwise answer, pointing out that our minds are very creative and capable of imagining radical things. Therefore we should not trust what we imagine in our minds to be true.

Dennis’s main points seems to be:

  1. God is imagined in our minds
  2. Morality can be determined by the common sense of the majority

Frank went on to reveal the logical fallacy in each of these. 

First, if God is imagined in our minds and we cannot trust what we think, then how can we trust anything that we think?  If our minds cannot be trusted, then how can an Atheists trust their minds when they imagine there is no God?  The only way we can trust anything is by evaluating the evidence in the world – and that evidence points to God.  Also, if we live in just a material world, a world without spirituality, than we do not have a soul or a mind that is separate from our physical brains, so we have no reason not to trust whatever our brain cells tell us because it is all we have to go on and has been trusted to get us this far.

To assume we have a free will to make decisions about what is true is to assume we are more than just molecules in motion, that we have a mind or a soul that is separate.  But this is part of the theist worldview, that we have a mind or soul that is separate from our brains.  Therefore, it takes a theist worldview to argue that God is just something we have imagined.  When Frank pointed this out, the Atheist moderator saved Dennis from having to respond.

Second, if morality can be determined by the common sense of the majority than why has the majority never in history been able to make good moral judgments?  In other words, the history of humanity proved this to be false.  Groups of people have agreed to be the most wicked and violent killers in the history of the world.  If fact, it was even an angry mop that voted to kill Jesus – an innocent man.  

If life has no meaning, than no one can determine morality and the majority is just a group of people that have no framework or standard to determine morality. Without a moral standard defined outside of humanity, humanity is destine to fail, so the only way for humanity to survive is by God to give us his standard – which is exactly what he did in giving us the bible.

Wow did Frank do an excellent job clearly communicating the most convincing evidence that could not be refuted that God must exist.  The logical result is that the claims of Jesus are also true, Jesus came to give his life for our redemption and save all who believe in him.  

Here is the full debate:

Current Catalog

Reader Comments

Be the first to leave a comment!
Write a Comment

Please keep comments civil and on-topic. Abusive or inappropriate comments will be removed without warning.

 Name (required)   
 Email Address (required)   
 Website URL 
The Victory of Reason: How Christianity Led to Freedom, Capitalism, and Western Success

Rodney Stark tells how Christianity gave rise not only to visions of reason and progress but also to the construction of capitalism. Stark shows that Christianity is a forward-looking religion, with bold faith in progress and in its followers' abilities to understand God over time. It was this future-based rational theology that encouraged the development of technical and organizational advances, such as the monastic estates and universities of the Middle Ages. Stark concludes by maintaining that Christianity continues to spread in places like Africa, China and Latin America because of its faith in progress. One could draw a conclusion from this work, that Christianity is the cornerstone of global economic development.

God Is Great, God Is Good: Why Believing in God Is Reasonable and Responsible

This book answers the contemporary complaints against belief in God which are addressed with intellectual passion and rigor by some of the most astute theological and philosophical minds in alive today. Atheism is no longer simply about `not believing' in a God or an intelligent designer. They have become angry and intolerant at anyone that believes in God. The evidence of creation and the daily worship of those that love God is a constant grind on the soul of those that reject the reality of God. Just as the scripture tells us, there is no rest for the soul of man that rejects God. Yet Christianity contains all the answers and reveals that God is indeed Good and Great are his works.

God's Not Dead: Evidence for God in an Age of Uncertainty

This point shows that there is overwhelming and exciting evidence for God’s existence and the God who exists is indeed the God of the Bible. Presented in layman’s terms, this book addresses the most challenging topic of the twenty-first century. The evidence is undeniable. If anyone is willing to take an honest look at the evidence for God, they will come face to face with the reality of his existence. This book is a great tool for dialog with thinkers of today’s culture, filled with statements that cut the lies of the postmodern culture in pieces.

The Magic Man in the Sky: Effectively Defending the Christian Faith

Are Christians just kidding themselves? Are believers wasting their lives serving an imaginary friend in the clouds? And do Christians even have the courage to confront the hard questions about God's existence? If you are challenged with this question, then this is the book for you. The author directly addresses the doubts and fears of young Christians in a hostile culture. In a time of doubt and darkness, this book brings a confident and joyful message that God loves us, life has a purpose, and best of all, he can prove it.