Why Science Cannot Determine Human Value Or Derive A Moral Standard

By: Curtis Ophoven 0 Comments   9/9/2014

A few years ago, Sam Harison wrote a book called, “The Moral Landscape: How Science Can Determine Human Values,“ in which he tried to argue that science will one day will be able to determine a moral standard – by which could sustain society.   

The problem is that science is the study of causes.  Science is the study of what caused the universe and everything in it to come into existence.  But Atheism begins with the assumption that there is no cause to the beginning of the universe.   

If man is the god of the universe, then morality must be derived from each man, but since each man’s idea of what is good/evil or right/wrong is different, there is nothing common to connect each man’s opinions.  There is no way to determine whose opinion to live by and whose opinion not to live by.  There is also no way to convince someone that their opinion is wrong – because there is no standard by which to judge anyone’s opinion.  And because there is nothing to connect man’s opinions, there is no common meaning that can be derived from the collection of individual opinions.   

Without a Cause

Without meaning, there is no purpose. So the first assumption of Atheism, that there is no cause to the beginning of the universe, eliminates any meaning to connect each man’s opinions to form a standard for morality.  Apart from a cause, man cannot derive a common morality.  

If there is no meaning or purpose, then why do we live as if there is?  Why do we create laws and hold people accountable to a system of justice?  No other animal does this. Justice implies that we have a purpose in life and that when someone interrupts our life or unjustly takes something away from us, we have a right to justice.  Justice implies purpose, and our demands for justice proves that meaning exists.  Humanity is born with a hunger for justice which reveals who we really are.  The value of life begins with God, because he made us precious.    

If man is the god of the universe, and there is no meaning to life, then justice does not matter.  Our demand for justice is a demand for God.  Without justice there is no way to derive a system of thought or a moral standard capable of supporting a society in which people can live happy and content.  Our need for justice reveals our need for God, and not just any god, but a God that is holy and just and capable of punishment and reward (all powerful).   

God is Irreplaceable

This is the irresolvable problem of Secular Humanism/Atheism that will forever plague the idea that there is no God.  God is irreplaceable.  God is needed for any rational determination of how we live.   

This is why Secular Humanism/Atheism will never grow into a large percentage of the population. Its foundational assumptions are false.  It is self-defeating.  History points out that whenever Secular Humanism/Atheism has increased, death and collapse soon follow, replaced by a people of religious convictions.  

This is why the New Atheism movement is intellectually bankrupt – just as God said it would be. The Bible tells us how the history of the world will unfold and at no time does the world become Atheistic. In fact, just the opposite happens; rather than moving to eliminate religions from the world, religions grow in power, and at some point, their power is consolidated to form a global religion as the fourth world empire appears.  This is described in the books of Daniel and Revelations.  

The New Atheism movement has no future, but it does have a purpose.  The purpose of the New Atheism movement is to lead the nations of the world away from Christianity and into the false religion of Secular Humanism.  And they are not alone. The New Atheism movement is just one part of the global rebellion against Christ that is underway.  


Current Catalog

Reader Comments

Be the first to leave a comment!
Write a Comment

Please keep comments civil and on-topic. Abusive or inappropriate comments will be removed without warning.

 Name (required)   
 Email Address (required)   
 Website URL 
Demolishing Supposed Bible Contradictions Volume 1

One of the most popular misconceptions by people who have walked away from the Church and their faith is that the Bible contains errors or inaccurate accounts. Many people also simply accept without question the claim by others that the Bible is full of contradictions. Even more disturbing is that a growing number of Christians are unable to respond when presented with an apparent inconsistency in the Bible. This book is a bold defense for the accuracy of Scripture.

What’s So Great About Christianity

This book is a response to the culture and media that continues to lie about Christianity. This is a passionate and intellectual presentation of the strengths and historical truths of Christianity. No other religion has brought the world greater rewards than Christianity, because no other religion contains a greater love given to the world by its creator. Without the unquestionable result Christianity, the world would not have been able to sustain itself and would have already been overtaken by death. We live in a time when atheism is attacking Christianity. This book reminds us that Christianity sustains the world.

The Case for a Creator: A Journalist Investigates Scientific Evidence That Points Toward God

Former journalist and skeptic Lee Strobel has discovered something very interesting about science. Far from being the enemy of faith, science may now provide a solid foundation for believing in God. Has science finally discovered God? Certainly new discoveries in such scientific disciplines as cosmology, cellular biology, astronomy, physics and DNA research are pointing to the incredible complexity of our universe, a complexity best explained by the existence of a Creator.

Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design

This book is arguably the best case for intelligent design as of 2011. Meyer shows the empirical evidence, and historical scientific reasoning. Without a question, the evidence of how DNA is constructed points to a very intelligent designer. No one in the scientific community has any other reasonable explanation for the signature of an intelligent designer that has been uncovered by DNA research.